Welcome to Nico's Pizza
Nico's Pizza, located at 255 Cougar Blvd in Provo, Utah, is a culinary gem that offers a delightful array of pizza options that will please any palate. Known for their creative flavors, the Bunker Hill pizza features an irresistible house-made creamy vinaigrette with grilled chicken and crispy bacon, while the Queen Margotte showcases fragrant pesto paired with fresh tomatoes and spinach. Customers rave about the exceptional quality and reasonable prices, highlighting the mouthwatering flavors and perfectly cooked crusts. With customizable calzones and a variety of refreshing salads, Nico's Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking both taste and value.
-
255 Cougar Blvd, Provo, UT 84604, United States255 Cougar Blvd, Provo, UT 84604, United States Hotline: +1 801-356-7900
Welcome to Nico's Pizza, an inviting culinary gem located at 255 Cougar Blvd, Provo, UT. With a focus on quality ingredients and exceptional flavor, Nico's has rapidly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or simply looking for a satisfying meal, Nico's Pizza has something to tantalize your taste buds.
At the heart of Nico's menu are their classic pies. Each pizza is crafted with care, starting from their signature Nico's tomato sauce that graces every slice. Indulge in the rich flavors of the Threecheese Nico's, which combines cheddar, Romano, and lots of whole milk mozzarella. For those who crave tradition, the Pepperoni is a must-try, showcasing pepperoni atop that heavenly tomato base. Feeling adventurous? The Hawaiian brings a delightful pairing of Canadian bacon and juicy pineapple, while the Spicy Hawaiian adds a kick with pepperoni and green pepper. And, if you're a fan of vibrant, fresh flavors, the Margherita with its hearty house tomato sauce, garlic, and basil is a slice of pure bliss.
Nico's Pizza isn’t just about pizza; their menu offers a variety of pasta and salads to round out your meal. Choose from options like fettucini and stuffed shells, paired with your choice of sauce. For a refreshing counterpart to your pie, the Caesar Salad — complete with shredded parmesan and croutons — is a perfect choice. Or try the Caprese Salad, a fresh combination of tomatoes and mozzarella drizzled with olive oil and balsamic glaze, perfect for those seeking a burst of flavor.
Customer experiences at Nico's shine through in glowing reviews. Skyler Swaney, a self-professed regular, lauds the exceptional staff and delicious, reasonably priced food. Heather Oxborrow sings praises for her flavorful Bunker Hill slice and the generous servings that make dining here a pleasure. Reviewers like Brady Crump and Rich E have even compared Nico's offerings favorably to famed New York pizzerias, emphasizing the extraordinary taste and quality.
With customizable options like calzones and a menu that caters to diverse tastes, Nico's Pizza stands as a pillar of taste in Utah’s culinary scene. From the moment you step through the doors, you're welcomed not just as a customer, but as part of a passionate community that loves good food. So whether it's a casual weekday dinner or a lively pizza party, Nico's Pizza is the spot to satisfy your cravings. Come hungry and leave happy!
I came here on a whim one day because it was right next to the UPS store. I have been converted into a regular customer. The staff are exceptional and the food is delicious and very reasonably priced. I’ve been looking for a good by the slice pizza place. I have yet to be disappointed by a flavor!
We loved pizza here! When I ordered my pizza combo with breadstick I thought it was just one, out came 4! I got the Bunker Hill slice and loved it, such great flavor combinations. My husband got a pepperoni slice and the rest of the night commented how good it was. We felt it was also such a great deal, so many other places are so expensive this was refreshing.
Nico’s pizza is so good! No complaints at all! The flavors, ingredients, the dough and how it was cooked, all perfect. I recently went to New York and tried multiple famous pizza places, and Nico’s was honestly better. Loved it! Our kids loved it too, saying it’s their favorite pizza place. Also, the breadsticks looked kind of meh, but ended up tasting amazing!
Delicious calzones that are fully customizable. The pesto pizza was killer. I will be returning to try their other pizzas :)
If you like Boston Style Pizza and you are in Utah, you have to go to Nico’s. I walked in skeptical and left very very happy! ordered a large cheese, well done crispy and they knew exactly what that meant ! It was so good, I thought about ordering another pie to go. I’m already looking forward to my next visit. Nicely done Nicos.....keep up the great work!
This isn't your run-of-the-mill pizza joint. You can tell they take pride in their craft, yet they maintains a simple, unpretentious vibe. The walls are decorated with a smorgasbord of iconic local pictures, awards, and custom artwork. The custom artwork shows some of the personality of the restaurant. Service here is counter-style, it’s casual, but that doesn’t mean careless. The staff at Nico's are as polite and helpful as they come, ready to assist with a smile. Ordering was a breeze. We ordered some salads, split an order of wings, and each got a slice. The garden and Greek salads had crisp, fresh veggies. My Greek Salad was dressed in a house-made dressing—something like I had never tried. It’s creamy and bursting with flavor. It's so good, in fact, that it found its way not only onto my salad but also as a dip for my pizza slice. I’ve lived in New York City and near Buffalo, I have a pretty high standard for wings and have eaten some great pizza. Nico's passed the test with flying colors. The wings here are best-in-class. I ordered the dry rub version. Flavorful, but not really spicy. I could have enjoyed some more spice, but in no way lacking flavor. I had mine with ranch, but I sampled the house dressing with these two—both were great. The real star of the show is, undoubtedly, the pizza. The slice of Nico's Special I had could easily hold its own against the best of New York. The method of baking the pizza then reheating the slice upon order results in a crust that's the perfect balance of crispy and tender, slightly blistered and lightly charred from its time on the stone. My friend opted for the Italian Stallion, a bold, sauceless creation featuring steak, pepperoni, spinach, and a delightful punch of garlic. After just one bite, I knew what I'd be ordering on my next visit. In sum, Nico's Pizza is a gem. With its 5-star quality food, friendly service, and unique atmosphere; I will definitely be back. This is easily the best pizza in Utah.
100% would return. Haley at the front was SO kind and helpful. It really set the tone for the whole experience. The pizza options were amazing (love that we could half and half on the specialties). I loved that I could add bread sticks or side salad and drink. My son was so excited about the freestyle machine - not that common anymore!
My girlfriend and I were looking for a late-night spot to grab a bite and stumbled upon Nico's Pizza—and we're so glad we did! From the moment we walked in, the girl cashier greeted us with a warm, friendly welcome that instantly made us feel at home. The pizza was absolutely delicious—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. Their house sauce deserves a special shoutout too—it was spot on and really brought everything together. We’ll definitely be back, and we highly recommend it to anyone in the area!